Bank Poll: Where Is Your Primary Checking Account?

There has been a lot of commotion about banks and debit card fees recently. Fees were tested, added, announced, removed, and probably soon, added back indirectly. However, megabanks still have the power of inertia and convenience. I am betting that most people did not move their accounts just yet. But maybe I’m wrong?

For this poll question, I want you to think about your current primary checking account. This is the account where the bulk of your paycheck or other income is deposited, and out of which you pay your bills on a regular basis.

Where Is Your Primary Checking Account?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

(RSS readers: You may need to visit the website to see the poll.)

I have a lot of accounts, but my primary checking account is online-only Ally Bank, as previously reviewed. I do keep a megabank account for the occasional need for in-branch services like a signature guarantee, cashier’s checks, bank wires, large checks that I can’t use eDeposit, and so on.

Citizens Bank / Charter One CollegeSaver Account: Potential 6% Annual Return (For Kids, Limited States)

Citizens Bank and Charter One bank have an interesting CollegeSaver bank account for those with children. However, it is only open to residents of certain states in the Eastern and Northeastern US (CT, DE, IL, IN, KY, MA, MI, NH, NJ, NY, OH, PA, RI, VT; enter zip code to verify). Thanks to reader Justin for the tip.

You must open a bank account before the child’s 12th birthday with a minimum amount, and then save a minimum amount every month until the child is 18. (You’re allowed to miss one payment per year.) If you satisfy the requirements, you’ll get a $1000 bonus on the 18th birthday. Here are the details:

The best case scenario would be if your kid is just under 12 years old right now. That’s still a 6-year commitment, but if you contribute the minimums then with the bonus that’s a 6.40% annual rate of return on your money (per savings calculator). Since the bonus is constant, the rate of return drops the younger your kid is (longer contribution period). At just over 6 years old, you’d be locked in for 12 years and your annualized return would be 1.9%.

I would say if your child is 10-12 years old and you have patience, this is not a bad deal. But as this is not a 529, you will owe taxes on the interest. However, the upside is that you don’t have to use the funds to pay for college. The account is opened as a custodial account (UTMA), and thus the account can be opened for the child by anyone. However, depending on the state, the child will get control of the account at 18 or 21.

Citi Checking Account Bonus $200/$400 in Gift Cards

Citibank is offering new checking account customers a bonus of either a 20,000 or 40,000 ThankYou points, worth $200 or $400 in gift cards. You must:

  • Open a new Citibank checking account in the Citigold or Citibank Account Package by 10/31/2011.
  • Enroll the new checking account in Citi ThankYou Rewards.
  • Within 45 days after account opening, initiate one direct deposit AND complete one electronic bill payment for two consecutive months.

ThankYou Point Value Recap
There are a decent number of options for these poitns. 10,000 ThankYou points = $100 Wal-mart Gift card, which you can sell for a $95.55 Amazon.com gift certificate or $91 cash at PlasticJungle.com. Alternatively, can be worth $100 towards Expedia travel, a student loan, or paying down your mortgage. More details in the Citi $500 ThankYou card post.

Citibank Account: 20,000 ThankYou Point Bonus (Easier)

  • $100 minimum opening deposit
  • $6,000 minimum balance in linked accounts (checking, savings, personal, credit card balances) to avoid $20 monthly fee.

Citigold Account: 40,000 ThankYou Point Bonus (Harder)

  • $500 minimum opening deposit
  • There’s no monthly service fee for the first 2 statement cycles. After that, in order to waive the $30 monthly service fee you need the combined average balance of your eligible linked accounts to be:
    • $50,000 or more for all linked deposit and retirement accounts OR
    • $100,000 or more across all your eligible linked Citi accounts, excluding a first mortgage with Citibank OR
    • $250,000 or more if your Citibank first mortgage is included in the total relationship.

For most people, I think the 20,000 ThankYou point offer will be the easier one to qualify for if you have $6,000 to move over there instead of an online savings account earning only 1% APY. $6,000 would only earn $60 over an entire year, at that rate. Even it takes 6 months to get your $200 bonus, that’s a 6.67% annualized return.

I thought that the Citigold might be doable since the monthly fees are waived for the first two months, but I saw in the fine print that the points might take another 90 days to post and your account must be open until then. This option would only work well if you have a mortgage with Citi.

The bonus ThankYou Points will be credited to your ThankYou Member Account within 90 days from the end of the statement period in which you satisfy all offer requirements. New checking account must be open and in good standing at the time the bonus ThankYou Points are posted to your ThankYou Member Account.

Afterwards, if you wish, you can downgrade to the Basic Account which offers a way to avoid monthly fees with no minimum balance, if you make 5 “qualified transaction” activities per month (direct deposits, debit card purchase, bill payment, ACH payments, checks paid, ATM withdrawals).

Update: Citibank has updated their checking account to have different restrictions starting with statements ending on 12/9/2011.

Chase Bank $125 New Checking Bonus In-Branch or Online

Chase Bank is offering a $125 bonus for new customers if you open a new Total Checking account with $100 and set up direct deposit within 60 days of account opening. They state that the direct deposit must be “an electronic deposit from your employer or the government of your paycheck, pension or government benefits (such as Social Security)”, but I’m not sure if they manually check. You must keep the account open for 6 months. To avoid a monthly fee, you must do one of the following each statement period:

  1. have at least one direct deposit of $500 or more post to your account (two or more direct deposits that add up to $500 or more do not qualify), or
  2. keep a minimum daily balance of $1,500 or more in your checking account, or
  3. keep an average balance of $5,000 or more in qualifying accounts with Chase.

Otherwise, a $12 monthly Service Fee will apply ($10 monthly Service Fee in CA, OR and WA). Per the fine print, if are not a current customer and you’ve closed an account more than 90 days ago, you count as a “new” customer again. However, you can only receive one checking account-related bonus per calendar year. Thanks to reader Andy for the tip. Offer expires 10/7/11.

Ally Bank 5-Year CD Rate (Drop) History

As part keeping the interest rate on my emergency fund as high as possible, I’ve shared my like of rewards checking, savings bonds, and the Ally Bank 5-Year CD. Ally CDs have a small 60-day interest withdrawal penalty, so the liquidity is still quite good. As long as you hold it for 6 months, you’ll be earning more interest than the highest rate from an online savings account even after the penalty is factored in. After that, the effective rate just keeps getting better until you reach maturity at the full rate.

With no minimum balance requirements, you can also buy them in whatever size chunks you want. And I have. But I checked the rates again today, and was sad to see they’ve been dropping quite fast recently. The current Ally Bank 5-year CD rate is 1.60% APY (as of 10/25/13). I decided to compile the rate history from as far back as I’ve been tracking them.

There have been a few small rate hikes, but for the most part the rate has been gradually dropping due to market conditions. If you’ve been thinking about buying, I would buy now before rates drop even farther. When opening a CD, remember they have a “10 Day Best Rate Guarantee” in which you get the best rate they offer within 10 days of opening. You can now also find slightly better rates elsewhere, for example Alliant Credit Union has their 5-year certificate at 2.35% APY (2.45% for $25k+), but with a larger 6-month interest penalty. I’ll probably still buy a little more at 2.17%, but if the rate drops below 2% then I’m looking elsewhere.

Capital One Bank Really Doesn’t Like Inactive Checking Accounts…

Banks aren’t as wildly profitable anymore, and thus are looking for ways to bring back the bucks. They’ve added new “features” like debit card fees, and are dropping unprofitable customers. For example, people with zero balances and little activity still cost money in the form of generating statements, 1099s, and such. Well, MMB reader Mike experienced firsthand how much Capital One Bank doesn’t like inactive checking accounts.

Even though he has biweekly direct deposits into his account, his account suddenly disappeared one day from online banking. It’s the primary fear of online-only accounts; what happens if they simply say my money doesn’t exist? After contacting them, what was the reason given for closing without notice? A $0 balance for just five consecutive days. Here are some excerpts of his exchange with customer service:

We understand you are inquiring about the status of your checking account. Your checking account ending in XXXX was closed on 08/19/2011 after an extended period with a zero balance. We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause. To have your account reactivated, please confirm you mailing address and phone number by secure message.

In regards to your question of $2,000 deposit once a month, our records indicate this last deposit made into the account was on 08/12/2011 for $2,278.44. Following this deposit on 08/12/2011 there was a withdrawal of $2,278.44, followed by a $20.00 ATM withdrawal on 08/15/2011 leaving the balance of this account at $0.00. Once the account has a zero balance for five consecutive days, it will close automatically and no longer appear in your online banking profile.

In the past, banks like EmigrantDirect also closed zero balance accounts without warning, but only after at least a month of inactivity. Watch out, banks are becoming even less friendly than before.

Wells Fargo, Chase Bank Testing Monthly Fees for Debit Card Usage

The fees are coming! Since February, Chase Bank has been testing out a monthly fee for anyone who uses their ATM debit card for purchases in areas of Northern Wisconsin. Regions Bank and Suntrust have added fees as well. Per this CNN Money article, Wells Fargo Bank just announced that it will start charging a $3 monthly fee for debit card usage next month in Georgia, New Mexico, Nevada and Oregon. (I guess they’re afraid of messing around in California just yet.) According to this WSJ article, Wells Fargo is only announcing this fee with one of those small inserts in your monthly statements, so heads up.

I know there has been drama over debit card interchange fees, but that was just a result of two big lobbying groups – small businesses vs. big banks. It was really not about consumer rights. The result was a new law that caps debit card interchange fees at 21 cents + 0.05% of the sale amount for banks with $10 billion or more in assets. Smaller banks with debit rewards like PerkStreet (review) say that this will not affect them.

I never use my debit card for purchases, so I would not be affected by any of this. Credit cards offer more consumer protection against fraud and things like extended warranties and free insurance, on top of the ability to delay payment for 15-30 days of float. More importantly, credit card rewards are better which means more money in my pocket. However, many people do like the simplicity of debit cards for purchases. If they don’t want to pay the fees, I hope they will vote with their money and move it immediately to bank that doesn’t charge such fees. Don’t expect banks to care about your angry internet comments; affect their bottom line and they’ll listen.

3.25% APY Savings Account – Deposit Limits, Ohio Residents Only

Reader Alison shares a unique savings account program for residents of Ohio. The SaveNOW program is a higher interest savings account supported by the state in order to encourage savings. The maximum balance on this account is $5,000 and pays 3.25% APY. The fine print regarding deposit limits is a bit confusing. It says:

Limits single deposits to $500 at a time with the exception of lump sum payments such as; a tax return, insurance settlement or inheritance payment

If I read this to mean that each resident to deposit a maximum of $500, every other year, then it would take nearly 20 years to reach the maximum? Otherwise, you might overpay taxes to max out the benefit. In any case, this is not going to make anyone rich, but can be a nice incentive given the program’s goals. A couple could deposit $1,000 every other year up to $10,000 combined.

Does anyone know of similar programs for other states?

Best Banks With Consistently High Interest Rates – 2013 Edition

Will the rate on your high-yield savings account stay high? It’s always hard to tell. Some do, and some banks seem to just give up. The NY Times Bucks blog shared a list of the top 10 banks offering high savings accounts rates over time for the 1st quarter of 2013 as compiled by MoneyRates, of which nine banks that have made the list for three quarters in a row. I’ve looked up their current APYs as well.

Bank Name
Historical Rate
(for ranking purposes)
Current Savings Account Rate (APY)
Discover Bank
1.16%
0.85% APY
1.13%
0.85% APY
1.10%
0.75% APY
Ally Bank
1.01%
0.85% APY

Capital One 360 Financial Independence Day Promotions

Capital One 360 is running their usual “Financial” Independence Day promotion. Valid only July 1st & 2nd, 2011 (why not until the 4th? who knows).

  • New 360 checking account customers will receive an opening bonus of $50 when they make three purchases within 45 days of account opening. Those that then set up and make at least two direct deposits of $250 by August 31st will receive an additional $76 bonus for a total savings of $126.
  • Investors who open a new ShareBuilder account will receive a $76 account bonus after their first investment.

Capital One’s Non-Response to ING Direct Purchase

Per many reports from Reuters and WSJ and more, Capital One is buying online bank ING Direct. After being bailed out by the Dutch government in 2008, parent company ING Groep NV was required to sell the US bank by 2013 as part of their restructuring plan. Other major suitors included Ally Bank and General Electric.

So while a takeover was expected, many people were unhappy with the announcement that the were soon to be customers of Capital One. They were rightly afraid the stubbornly simple and straightforward bank culture would change. I personally didn’t really care, banks change all the time and I just go with whomever has the best rate and feature combo available right now. ING Direct has been content with “just good enough” rates for a while. Here’s where I keep my cash these days, I’m earning much more than 1%.

However, the NYT Times Bucks blog ran an interview with Capital One about the sale yesterday, and it was just too horrible not to make fun of. Read the original, real interview first, with more vague, lawyer-approved, corporate double-talk you could imagine. In my *parody* version below, let’s imagine what they’d say if allowed to be brutally honest.

Q: Why are customers of ING so upset about the sale of their bank to Capital One?

ING Direct was known for simplicity, directness, and good customer service. Capital One is known mostly for credit cards that don’t properly report credit limits to bureaus so it hurts your credit scores, a surprisingly good foreign transaction fee model, and TV ads with Vikings and Alec Baldwin.

Q: What changes are you planning to make to ING Direct’s account offerings? Will subaccounts for specific savings goals remain?

Well, many good features including that one are already in place and it would be really, really stupid to mess it up. But the lawyers won’t let me commit to anything in writing or they will eat a kitten.

Q. Are you planning any new fees or minimum balance requirements?

If we think it will make us more money in the end, then hell yeah.

Q: Does the reaction suggest Capital One might need to enhance customer service? How might this be done?

Yes. No idea.

Q. Will ING Direct be operated separately or integrated into Capital One’s operations?

Look, we just saw over $80 billion in bank deposits paying out just 1% interest. Do you have any idea how much interest we’d get paid by lending that out to people with our credit cards??? Cha-ching!

To repeat: These are a parody. I am actually a satisfied customer that has used a CapOne credit card for international purchases for several years. But hopefully they’ll realize that bland PR talk does not make more engaged, passionate customers.

Fidelity App now has BillPay, Funds Transfer, & Remote Check Deposit

Fidelity Investments has just added some handy new features to their Apple iOS and Android OS apps. You can now use their BillPay service, transfer funds between accounts, and deposit checks remotely via camera. Before, you were limited to viewing account holdings and making trades. Competition is good, and I expect all major banks and brokerages to offer these features soon.

Mobile Check Deposit
Basically the same as other apps, you take a picture of the front and back with your smartphone camera. You can deposit only into non-retirement accounts, and the back must be endorsed with the text “For deposit only to Fidelity account #XXXXXX”. The deposit limits vary.

BillPay & Funds Transfer
You can pay bills with your mobile app, either through a regular brokerage account or their mySmart Cash Account (basically their checking account replacement product). Fidelity also allows you to link outside banks to your accounts, so now you can initiate money transfers both within Fidelity and externally on your phone.